aj12754's Profile

From: Montclair, NJ USA

Joined: November 22nd, 2009

About me: I can't be the only person who starts thinking about what to cook next while I am doing the dishes for the meal I just finished eating ... right?

Favorite cookbook: I flirt with all of them. But I am a sucker for good writing and great pictures.

Favorite recipe: Pretty much any combo of good bread and great cheese.


Latest review:

June 20th, 2020

Slow-Roasted Tomatoes from One Good Dish

A dish that could not be simpler to make, and absolutely delicious. Topped the cooled tomato with a room temperature slice of mozzarella drizzled with EVOO and some ribbons of basil. A real treat. read more >


recipe reviews (696)
book reviews (39)
useful review votes (442)

aj12754's Reviews


Search Reviews:

8 recipe(s) reviewed. Showing 1 to 8Sort by: Title | Date | Rating

Barefoot Contessa at Home: Everyday Recipes You'll Make Over and Over Again

By Ina Garten
Clarkson Potter - 2006

25th November 2009

Broccolini and Balsamic Vinaigrette : page 135

Enjoyable side dish if you are a broccoli/broccolini fan. Easy and can be served warm or cool. Can easily vary flavor by using a small amount of minced shallot in place of the garlic.

useful (0)  


23rd September 2011 (edited: 23rd September 2011)

Garlic & Herb Tomatoes : page 130

These were just fine and very easy. Exceptionally pretty presentation when you use a variety of cherry tomatoes in different colors.

They are meant to be a side dish but I think either Mark Bittman's tomato cobbler or Smitten Kitchen's scalloped tomatoes are a more interesting side.

I think these would be excellent however tossed with some pasta and mozzarella ... a very nice and quick summer dinner.

useful (1)  


21st November 2011

Guacamole Salad : page 85

I thought this was good, not great. It is basically a black bean salad. No corn is involved but the flavor is good and would have been even better if I had made it a few hours in advanced and let it sit at room temperature (minus the avocados which should be added just before serving) for a while. A hit of fresh chopped cilantro probably would have taken this to a four or five.

useful (2)  


4th February 2010 (edited: 12th November 2010)

Panna Cotta with Balsamic Strawberries : page 190

My all-time favorite summer dessert. Ina credits Mario Batali as the source of this recipe and she is certainly taking inspiration from the right direction.

This is incredibly simple -- it is basically heavy cream/yogurt jello sweetened with sugar and enriched with both vanilla extract and a vanilla bean. It looks beautiful for summer entertaining when surrounded by the Balsamic strawberries and topped with a little orange zest. It would also be delicious served in a puddle of fresh blackberry sauce and topped with a bit of lemon zest or a dollop of lemon curd.

It is very rich so I use my smallest (4 oz.) ramekins.

useful (0)  


15th October 2010 (edited: 15th October 2010)

Portobello Lasagna : page 112

We enjoyed this but probably not enough to make it again. It was very simple to make -- a quick bechamel, some sauteed mushrooms (I used a mix of portobello, cremini, and shiitake), and grated Parmesan. The flavor was just a little one-note. Maybe some thyme or some white or red wine added to the mushrooms would boost the flavor.

useful (0)  


4th February 2010

Roasted Pepper and Goat Cheese Sandwiches : page 46

I didn't follow this recipe as written since I was in a hurry and made the executive decision to used roasted red peppers from a jar. No matter -- still delicious. The tang of goat cheese with the peppers and fresh basil is just delicious. This is a handsome-looking sandwich as well -- the colors of summer.

The recipe calls for the addition of capers to the vinaigrette the peppers marinate in -- I love 'em but have family members who don't and I don't think it hurts the recipe any to leave them out.

useful (0)  


25th November 2009

Stewed Lentils and Tomatoes : page 144

I am a fan of lentils and this is an easy and delicious way to eat a healthy meal. It is similar to Ina's other lentil recipes but adds some curry powder to good effect.

useful (0)  


26th April 2011

Warm Duck Salad : page 78

Although I gave this salad a 4, my husband insists it is a 5 and he may be right. I am not much of a raspberry fan (pretty as they are in this salad) and that may have affected my review.

There is a lot to like about this salad. Very easy to do. Duck and oranges -- a classic combination. The toasted pecans add a nice crunch (and I think Smitten Kitchen's candied pecans might be good here too). For me the raspberries added more color than flavor; next time I might try blackberries instead since I prefer them.

The sherry vinaigrette with orange zest worked very well. The recipe called for a mix of baby lettuces and endive. I mixed a bit of mesclun, some frisee, a small romaine heart and one endive and was very happy with the result. We found that one duck breast was enough for two salads.

Finally -- I loved the method of cooking the duck breast -- on a sheet pan skin side up in a 425 oven for 20 minutes. No need to score the skin -- just salt it and in oven it goes. I worried about duck fat spattering the interior of the oven -- but no. No spatter, no smoke, but a really nice aroma coming from the oven. You take it out, cover tightly with foil for 10-15 minutes and then remove the skin and slice the medium-rare duck into slim slices for the salad.

useful (1)