janiecem's Profile

From: Sammamish, WA

Joined: December 4th, 2009


Latest review:

May 29th, 2010

Creme Sauce (Sauce Supréme) from Joy of Cooking: 75th Anniversary Edition - 2006

Very buttery cream sauce with a wonderful flavor. read more >


recipe reviews (12)
book reviews (0)
useful review votes (3)

janiecem's Reviews


Search Reviews:

1 recipe(s) reviewed. Showing 1 to 1Sort by: Title | Date | Rating

The Escoffier Cookbook and Guide to the Fine Art of Cookery: For Connoisseurs, Chefs, Epicures Complete With 2973 Recipes

By Auguste Escoffier, H. L. Cracknell, R. J. Kaufmann, Charlotte Adams
Crown Publishers, Inc. - 1969

24th February 2010

Andalusian Salade : page 642

The salad came out pretty well, but the cookbook is very difficult. The recipes are really only guidelines, and this book is meant for professional chefs who know what they are doing. They aren't laid out the way most cookbook recipes are, with a list of ingredients right up front. It's a little more like The Joy of Cooking but still not easy to follow. An interesting thing is the lay-out of the chapters. Salads are included in the chapter on Roasts and Salads.

Here is the recipe for the salad:

Peel and quarter some small tomatoes; cut some mild peppers julienne-fashion; cook some rice plainly in salted water, keeping each grain separate; add a little crushed garlic and chopped onion and parsley.
Season with oil and vinegar.

That's it -- no quantities, no definition of mild peppers (I used some miniature bell peppers I happened to have). No idea how much rice, and how to keep the grains separate. Anyway, I used the little miniature peppers, one tomato (it's all I had), some leftover green onions, and enough rice to serve four, and bottled vinaigrette. It came out good, no leftovers, and my family gave it three stars.

The cookbook is valuable for its sauces and its historical nature, but not a cookbook I would recommend for the casual family chef. I'd give it 3.5 stars overall.

useful (1)