Website: Smitten Kitchen

Classic Grilled Cheese + Cream of Tomato Soup
Page: smittenkitchen.com/2006/11/come-on-thunder/
Cuisine: North American | Course Type: Main Courses
Tags:
Single Review Display
aj12754 from Montclair, NJ
Rainy, misty, chilly days are perfect days for serving soup and a sandwich -- so this was perfect for last night's dinner. This soup is a bit more work (seed removal and then roasting the canned tomatoes after sprinkling them with brown sugar) than my usual recipe (from Great American Food without Fuss) and I am not sure it is significantly better than that recipe. But it is a good recipe and a good soup.
Like Deb, I kind of lost patience at the end and simply used my hand blender rather than strain the soup a 2nd time. Then I added the cream and -- off heat -- two tablespoons of sherry (which is a definite and welcome departure from my usual recipe).
Next time, I think I'd start with the Muir Glen Fire-roasted tomatoes and skip the roasting step. And I'd put the tomatoes through a food mill right up front rather than a strainer to get rid of the seeds. And next time I'll try the brandy option Deb suggests.
Like most soups, it has improved with time and made a fine dinner tonight as well, this time with a BLT instead of the grilled cheese sandwich.
I agree with BeckyL about the addition of some fresh herbs -- I am thinking a bit of thyme tossed in with the shallots. And basil later in the summer.
(edited 22nd April 2011) (0) comment (1) useful
Login or register to add your own review of this recipe.