aj12754's Profile

From: Montclair, NJ USA

Joined: November 22nd, 2009

About me: I can't be the only person who starts thinking about what to cook next while I am doing the dishes for the meal I just finished eating ... right?

Favorite cookbook: I flirt with all of them. But I am a sucker for good writing and great pictures.

Favorite recipe: Pretty much any combo of good bread and great cheese.


Latest review:

June 20th, 2020

Slow-Roasted Tomatoes from One Good Dish

A dish that could not be simpler to make, and absolutely delicious. Topped the cooled tomato with a room temperature slice of mozzarella drizzled with EVOO and some ribbons of basil. A real treat. read more >


recipe reviews (696)
book reviews (39)
useful review votes (442)

aj12754's Reviews


Search Reviews:

1 recipe(s) reviewed. Showing 1 to 1Sort by: Title | Date | Rating

Saveur Cooks Authentic French: Rediscovering the Recipes, Traditions, and Flavors of the World's Greatest Cuisine

By Colman Andrews, Dorothy Kalins, Christopher Hirsheimer
Chronicle Books - 1999

9th March 2011 (edited: 9th March 2011)

Soupe Paysanne a Boire et a Manger : page 74

This is basically a bean and vegetable soup. All the usual suspects are present (onions, leeks, garlic, carrots, shallots, celery, turnips, cabbage, navy beans). The veggies and a ham hock are sauteed in duck fat (or whatever oil you like), and then you add the beans and water (5 count 'em 5 quarts), bring to boil and then simmer for four hours.

My husband liked the end result, but I thought the veggies had basically leeched all their flavor into the broth. With so much cooking, there was also no real crunch or firmness to the veggies -- so the texture is almost silky.

The photo of the soup in this book shows it as a rich brown -- but mine (and I made no changes to the recipe) was more a golden yellow. And the recipe makes a ton of soup -- had to use my largest stockpot.

I ended up wishing I'd added some thyme when I sauteed the veggies -- and maybe added some blue cheese to the finished soup.

useful (0)