Search inside this book

No other editions

The Complete America's Test Kitchen TV Show Cookbook

Best Shortbread

Page 675

Cuisine: English/Scottish | Course Type: Cookies/Bars

(1 review)
View photos (1)

Tags:

Recipe Review

3rd December 2011

Peckish Sister from Central, FL

I was curious to see how this recipe compared to that of the Barefoot Contessa. There were major differences with the addition of oats, powdered sugar and cornstarch. The directions and pictures were very clear. Baking the shortbread in the collar of my 9.25” spring form pan opened on a rimmed baking sheet did not work for me as the fit was so tight it did not open any. When the short bread baked it wrinkled and flaked off in places as it had no where to expand. It might be a little trickier, but next time I would place the bottomless spring form on my largest un-rimmed baking sheet. I substituted rolled barley for the oats (food sensitivity). I had a hard time getting them ground into flour, ending up with lots of hard bits even when I sieved it. It was my own fault as I used a small food processor instead of the specified coffee grinder or blender. However, it is hard not to like real butter short bread. I love the shape of it, it tasted great and I will definitely make this recipe again.

(3) useful  

Comments

Leeka - 4th December 2011
Your shortbread looks great!

I'm about to make my first attempt at vegan shortbread today based on my mom's old recipe. I hope it turns out as lovely looking as yours.

 

Peckish Sister - 5th December 2011
Thank You so much. Close up you can see the imperfections, but when you take a bite - pure heaven. I will forward to hearing how yours turns out. I will never again be tempted by those large tins of Walker shortbread in Costco!

 

Queezle_Sister - 5th December 2011
Beautiful! Leeka - what will you substitute for the butter?

 

Login or register to add your own comments.