| It was quite bland, but not quite as bad as I had feared. I thought it was an interesting idea to use a Bechamel in a casserole, but that didn't necessarily help with the blandness. You'll need quite a number of pots and pans to prepare everything, but you can prepare it in advance quite easily so you'll just pop it in the oven at the very end. We loved the cheese and breadcrumb, though there definitely wasn't enough of it, especially not enough cheese. |
| The cake is not too bad, actually. Of course, it's sugarfree, and therefore not (very) sweet, and I'd definitely be disappointed with it as my birthday cake, but what does my son know? (I don't think it'll pass with his three-year old niece. I guess we'll have to give her a piece of the adult's cake).
It didn't really rise, though, and I'm not sure why. Lack of sugar shouldn't have anything to do with it, should it? I used 2 tsp of baking powder for just two handsful of batter! Will probably make cupcakes on the big day, as the cake looks pityfully flat even in our smallest cake dish.
Edited 25 March 2016:
I forgot to comment on the baking process. This is another baking recipe, similar to this one, where I suspect that the author had little idea of what she was doing. First you are instructed to mix flour, spices and baking powder; then to add the butter and rub it between your fingers until the mixture looks like fine bread crumbs - this latter step is a technique for making shortcrust pastry (hint: banana cake does not contain a shortcrust pastry. Not even this particular recipe.). Then you are instructed to mix the mashed bananas and the egg (= the wet ingredients) in a separate bowl, and at the very end, fold them into the flour mixture - classical muffin making technique, with the exception that butter is a wet ingredient and was supposed to go into the second bowl.
To make matters worse, the raisins go in one bowl, the walnuts into another - that doesn't make sense. Also, the walnuts are optional and can be added either finely chopped or ground - but if ground, they would change the ratio of dry vs. wet ingredients, the same way you can often substitute part of the flour with ground nuts of your choice.
Sometimes I think it's too bad Ms Rapley didn't ask a cook or a nutrionist (or both!) to help her write this book. |
| I made this cake once, about twelve years ago - I definitely wasn't as demanding culinarywise then as I am now, it appears. The cake is fine but a little boring. It features a fairly standard sponge, a few apples on top, then topped off by (the only interesting feature!) a nice crunchy crumble.
I actually forgot the cake in the oven - I baked it 1 hour and 15 min instead of the required 45 min, but that didn't seem to do any harm.
I think you could spruce it up, a little, by making the sponge layer thinner and adding in some spices - I'm thinking cardamom, but maybe also some chili? |
| The whole blog including this recipe has moved to the blog Sweet Happy Life, so my review moved on as well. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 5th January 2010)Quite impossible to cover 4 chicken leg portions with just a little marinade and 125 ml water – you’d have to have a darn perfect fitting pan to manage that. As similar chicken dishes had ended up being slightly dry in the past, I was careful to cover the chicken. After all, the point about stewing is to cook something in lots of liquid. Needless to say, I ended up with a sauce that was far too thin, even though I reduced the sauce for an extra ten minutes.
Otherwise it’s a very nice dish. It’s not as tasty as it smells, which could be due to slightly too much of sour ingredients (lime, mainly), so try to cut them back.
|
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 1st October 2009)A lovely dish from one of my favourite regions, though I replaced the pine nuts with equally suitable almonds.
One caveat: make sure that all pieces of meat are covered with liquid while cooking, otherwise you'll end up with small bits of the meat being dry. If this hadn't happened, I might even have given a 5-star rating.
Serve with rice or couscous. You could add extra liquid to prevent the chicken from drying out, and then cook couscous in some of that liquid, just as done in Chicken and Couscous One-pot.
Edited to add:
The recipe is available online here. You can also review it here. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 1st October 2009)A wonderful and sophisticated vegetarian tart, ideal for picnics and the like.
Edited to add:
The recipe is available online here. You can also review it here. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 1st October 2009)A healthy, delicious, and extremely easy dish - just put everything in a baking tray, bake, add some extra ingredients and you're done! |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 1st October 2009)Very delicious, though quite heavy and a slightly standard combination of ingredients. Use Homemade Pesto, if possible.
Edited to add:
The recipe is available online here. You can also review it here. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 1st October 2009)Easy, quick and delicious.
Use for e.g. Creamy Pesto Chicken with Roasted Tomatoes. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 22nd November 2009)Err... let’s call it a Risotto, shall we? 1 litre chicken stock was FAR too much for 300g rice. Besides that, the dish was pretty bland, so don’t even bother trying it... |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 22nd November 2009)Nice dish, works both as a vegetarian main and as a side dish.
Edited to add:
The recipe is available online here. You can also review it here. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 25th November 2009)This one was nice but tasted less of fish and more of other spices than my usual, very basic fish pie; also, it was definitely more work. I may repeat it, but chances are that I’ll rather hang on to the basic version... |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 25th November 2009)Wonderful dish! Easy to prepare, visually attractive and delicious in taste; and on top of that it falls into what BF calls the 'fire and forget'-category of dishes, giving you a whole hour to prepare other dishes and clean up before your guests arrive… |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 8th December 2009)Very delicious, true comfort food! Of course, this recipe suffers from the same problems as every other lasagne recipe I’ve seen until now: not enough sauce and cheese. You can easily double the tomato sauce, and add some extra herbs eg. thyme, while you’re at it. You might want to make some extra ‘white sauce’ (why not call it Béchamel?), but it’s not really necessary, just remember to push down the lasagne sheets before adding another layer of sauce. Also, add lot’s of salt and oil to the aubergines.
Another downside is that any lasagne will take quite some time to assemble. But it's worth it, at least with this recipe. Serves 6 women, or 4 hungry men.
Do you want to prepare this dish? You'll find the recipe online here.
Variations? See my Salmon Lasagna, or my review of Delicious Magazine's Classic Moussaka.
Edited 2 September 2014:
Continues to be a classic. Regarding quantities, I made a tomato sauce as suggested, but using 2 cans of tomatoes, no wine, most ingredients finely chopped by hand, and no stop-over at the food processor. I made the bechamel with 50 g butter/flour and about 600-700 ml milk, and I substituted one aubergine for a courgette, as the latter happened to linger in my fridge. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 8th December 2009)The good news: it's incredibly easy to prepare (just throw everything into a roasting tin and you're nearly done), it's beautiful and distinctly autumnal (it's the cover dish, for that matter), and BF and my guests last night loved it.
The bad news: I didn't. I was a bit disappointed because the flavours of the ingredients didn’t come together. What the sense of that? I thought cooking was the art of combining ingredients and creating something new. Instead, the chicken tasted like chicken (like a very tender chicken, though), the squash tasted like squash, the walnuts tasted like walnuts, and the sage, well, the sage was burnt and didn’t give off any flavour at all.
Edited to add:
The recipe is available online here. You can also review it here. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 15th December 2009)This recipe is nearly identical to the Mussels with Coriander Cream, Thai Style in Olive 101 Quick Fix Dishes, which is why I will cross-post my review here:
Mussels are always delicious, and I would probably find it hard not to award a 5 star rating to any mussel-dish that keeps it simple. This one is no exception. With coconut cream, fresh coriander and a hint of green curry, it's a welcome change to our usual dish of mussels in white wine.
I was careful with the green curry paste as I didn't want the sharpness to overpower the taste of the mussels, but that wasn't the case; using one teaspoon shouldn't be any problem. Also, we used coconut cream instead of coconut milk, which was a good move, but not enough, for my taste; I would have liked to have a thick sauce not unlike garlic sauce or mayonnaise for dipping. It might be worth it to either try to make an additional sauce based on coconut cream, or to add less white wine and use coconut milk for cooking instead.
You can serve this as a main for two persons, or as an appetizer for up to 6, I guess (the book suggests it is a main dish for 6, but that's humbug).
*****
Thai-spiced Steamed Mussels uses red curry paste instead of green one, chicken stock instead of white wine, and spring onions instead of a red onions (we used normal onions anyway). Additionally, it uses a red chilli, less garlic (2 instead of 4 garlic cloves) and more coconut milk (400ml instead of 142ml). I suspect that these differences won’t make any difference, except for the quantity of coconut milk, which I suspect will be far too much – we probably used no more than 300ml liquid in total for Mussels with Coriander Cream, and even that was a bit too much in my opinion. Using a total of 700ml liquid you’ll end up cooking your mussels, not steaming them. Another slight difference is that you add the garlic and spring onions at the end of the cooking process, without frying them. This is probably a question of personal preference, but I love the taste of roasted onions.
Recipe originally published in Economy Gastronomy by Allegra McEvedy & Paul Merrett. Don’t buy this book, this dish is anything but economic (app. 6 Euros per serving; serves 2, not 4, see review above). |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 15th December 2009)Very nice, definitely a new dish for my growing repertoire! The chicken was juicy and tender, the couscous creamy and very aromatic. We had carrots sautéed in apple butter (a variation of the Glazed Sautéed Carrots in The Cook’s Book) as a side dish, which was delicious, but any other root vegetable would have worked just as well.
Quite similar to Chicken with Saffron, Raisins and Pine Nuts from the same magazine, same edition
Edited to add:
The recipe is available online here. You can also review it here. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 8th January 2010)I passed this recipe on to my sister-in-law and asked her to tell me what she thought about it afterwards. She liked it a lot. She used rum instead of vodka and no water at all (must have been a fun evening). Crushing the cranberries was difficult, though, and you’ll end up with a lot of pulp and pits in the glasses; next time she’ll probably use a mortar to solve this problem (she pondered about using a blending machine and then sieving the juice but then figured that every mojito contains some pulp). |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 8th January 2010)Very delicious. In fact, the combination of flavours would have been worth a 5-star-rating if there hadn’t been so many smallish things to improve.
We cooked the Thai glutinous rice according to the package instructions, not according to the recipe, and it didn’t really work as it should have; there was too little water, and when the rice was finally cooked, it was more of a porridge with too little texture. Nothing of this is related to the recipe, of course, but if you do decide to make this dessert for guests, make sure that you know how to cook the rice. I might try normal dessert rice next time.
Furthermore, the rice was a little tasteless and watery. I would suggest cooking the rice in the coconut milk, perhaps adding the golden caster sugar half-way through the cooking process to prevent the sugar from becoming too caramelised. All in all, the rice could also have been sweeter; but if you decide to go for a sweet rice, serve only small portions of rice.
The sauce, then again, could easily have been a little more sour. The orange juice is superfluous, in my opinion, as it easily superimposes the taste of the mangoes; instead, liquidise the mango and add orange juice (or mango juice!) or water only when really necessary to reach the consistency of the sauce. Also add more lime juice – I think it’s just that contrast between a sweet, sticky, heavy rice and a fruity, light, and slightly sour sauce are rather desirable.
We left out the passion fruit and mint leaves entirely, but I’m sure they form a perfect addition.
PS: Curious? Check out the recipe here. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 11th January 2010)Basically very delicious, but not tasty enough, I thought. Perhaps that’s the way it should be, with no more but a faint taste of garlic – after all, garlic can be very overwhelming, and mash is a side dish that should rather stay in the background. Still, next time I’ll try it with an extra garlic clove next time and also crush the garlic and then see how that goes. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 6th March 2010)Nice. I would change a few things, but none of them is dramatic. I would probably add an egg (or perhaps two) to make the fish cakes stick better, and I would add more lime zest to the mayonnaise – I tried lime juice instead, but BF complained that that made the mayonnaise turn too sour (I didn’t even notice). Also, while I quite liked the dominant taste of the peas, I would probably use more fish and fewer peas to make the cakes have a stronger taste of fish.
Neither of us could be bothered with cutting chillies, although they probably would have been a good idea.
Edited to add:
The recipe is available online here. You can also review it here.
I tried a similar recipe, Salmon Cakes with Lemon Mayo from Olive: 101 Quick-fix Dishes, but I liked this version better.
Edited 8 January 2016:
We made these again last night. I used pangasius instead of trout, and as I had read several reviews on the BBC website saying the fish cakes were bland, I added quite a bit of dried dill. The resulting fish cakes were quite nice in taste - I didn't taste the dill at all, but I guess it helped anyway ( I would expect potentially bland fish cakes to taste even blander with a characterless fish as pangasius).
However, the texture was a complete failure - they already fell apart before they hit the pan! The only thing that helped a little was deep-frying them on high heat in lots of oil, but I only made two of those before I gave up, tossed them all back into a bowl and added an egg, and that really made a difference (I would still recommend deep-frying, though, if only for the crispness). Is there anything I missed that every proper Englishman knows about making fish cakes? Like, should I have chilled the fish cakes before frying them, is that the reason why I failed? I might actually give that a try some day... |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 6th March 2010)Basically this is a variation on my usual recipe of very basic Leek Tart, except that it features soft cheese with garlic and herbs and foregoes the egg-milk-cream mix. On the one hand I like the addition, on the other this might have been the reason why the crust didn’t become crisp at all (BF suggested a rating of only 3 stars at this point) – then again, an egg-milk-cream mix contains even more liquid, so we probably just didn’t give it enough time. It wasn’t quite enough for four, though.
We made this tart with (defrosted) mussels and shrimps instead of bacon, and the combination worked well, too.
Edited to add:
The recipe is available online here. You can also review it here. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 6th March 2010)Very hot. Taste the sauce before adding that one last chili pepper, it might not be necessary. Goes well with, err, lots of plain rice and a cold beer. Otherwise very delicious, and super quick, especially if you have already prepared the Green Seasoning in advance. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 6th March 2010)Great seasoning, easy to make. We used half for the Trini Prawn Curry, and froze the other half in ice cubes for the next dish. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 23rd March 2010)Slight disappointment. I had expected something as good as the Vegetable Pilau I hade made a few months ago, but this dish tasted quite disbalanced. DB compared it to an orchestra that made sufficient noise (read: was tasty/aromatic enough), but that noise wasn't guided properly as to produce a nice harmonic tune.
Granted, we had to use tomato purée instead of real tomatoes because BF had secretly eaten them up (all of them!), and then (whisper) he actually used the whole double-sized tin (140g)!! Consequently, the dish tasted too much of tomato purée, a slightly sour taste, but also the taste of the curry (we used mild madras) or perhaps the tumeric was too strong. Halfway through the meal we had the idea to add some rasped coconut to balance the spices a little more, which worked a little.
Next time we´ll definitely use fresh tomatoes, even if that means going out to the store again, and cut the curry and tumeric by half, and then see how it goes. I do believe that the basic idea is very nice.
Oh, by the way, would you like to try it out for yourself? Get the recipe here and post your recipe here. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 15th April 2010)Very delicious, true comfort food! Of course, this recipe suffers from the same problems as every other lasagne recipe I’ve seen until now: not enough sauce and cheese. You can easily double the tomato sauce, and add some extra herbs eg. thyme, while you’re at it. You might want to make some extra ‘white sauce’ (why not call it Béchamel?), but it’s not really necessary, just remember to push down the lasagne sheets before adding another layer of sauce. Also, add lot’s of salt and oil to the aubergines.
Another downside is that any lasagne will take quite some time to assemble. But it's worth it, at least with this recipe. Serves 6 women, or 4 hungry men.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food magazine, May 2009 edition.
Variations? See my Salmon Lasagna, or my review of Delicious Magazine's Classic Moussaka (including online recipe). |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 15th April 2010)A wonderful and sophisticated vegetarian tart, ideal for picnics and the like.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food magazine, June 2009 edition. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 15th April 2010)Nice dish, works both as a vegetarian main and as a side dish.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food magazine, June 2009 edition. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 15th April 2010)Very sophisticated ten minute (ehm, okay, 15 minute) pizzas. I absolutely loved the taste, it was fresh, varied, and it definitely showed that you can combine mozzarella with more than tomato and basil.
Our naan-bread was quite soggy, though. I liked it, the same way I I like a Domino's pizza once in a while. But I can also imagine that some might prefer something more crunchy. Baked/grilled baguette might be the solution here, and also makes it possible to serve it as finger food at your next party.
Beware that the quantities of the ingredients aren't completely right – we used only one instead of two courgettes and had some courgette leftovers, while the mozzarella was just enough. So that's a four star rating instead of five...
Crosspost. The online version of the recipe as it appeared in the BBC Olive magazine (but not in the BBC Good Food magazine), August 2009 edition. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 16th April 2010)Very delicious, though quite heavy and a slightly standard combination of ingredients. Use Homemade Pesto (online recipe also here), if possible.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food magazine, May 2009 edition. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 16th April 2010)A lovely dish from one of my favourite regions, though I replaced the pine nuts with equally suitable almonds.
One caveat: make sure that all pieces of meat are covered with liquid while cooking, otherwise you'll end up with small bits of the meat being dry. If this hadn't happened, I might even have given a 5-star rating.
Serve with rice or couscous. You could add extra liquid to prevent the chicken from drying out, and then cook couscous in some of that liquid, just as done in Chicken and Couscous One-pot.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food magazine, June 2009 edition. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 16th April 2010)Very nice, definitely a new dish for my growing repertoire! The chicken was juicy and tender, the couscous creamy and very aromatic. We had carrots sautéed in apple butter (a variation of the Glazed Sautéed Carrots in The Cook’s Book) as a side dish, which was delicious, but any other root vegetable would have worked just as well.
Quite similar to Chicken with Saffron, Raisins and Pine Nuts, both of which appeared both online and in the BBC Good Food magazine, June 2009 edition (see below).
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food magazine, June 2009 edition. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 16th April 2010)Nice. I would change a few things, but none of them is dramatic. I would probably add an egg (or perhaps two) to make the fish cakes stick better, and I would add more lime zest to the mayonnaise – I tried lime juice instead, but BF complained that that made the mayonnaise turn too sour (I didn’t even notice). Also, while I quite liked the dominant taste of the peas, I would probably use more fish and fewer peas to make the cakes have a stronger taste of fish.
Neither of us could be bothered with cutting chillies, although they probably would have been a good idea.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food magazine, Oct. 2009 edition. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 16th April 2010)Very delicious. In fact, the combination of flavours would have been worth a 5-star-rating if there hadn’t been so many smallish things to improve.
We cooked the Thai glutinous rice according to the package instructions, not according to the recipe, and it didn’t really work as it should have; there was too little water, and when the rice was finally cooked, it was more of a porridge with too little texture. Nothing of this is related to the recipe, of course, but if you do decide to make this dessert for guests, make sure that you know how to cook the rice. I might try normal dessert rice next time.
Furthermore, the rice was a little tasteless and watery. I would suggest cooking the rice in the coconut milk, perhaps adding the golden caster sugar half-way through the cooking process to prevent the sugar from becoming too caramelised. All in all, the rice could also have been sweeter; but if you decide to go for a sweet rice, serve only small portions of rice.
The sauce, then again, could easily have been a little more sour. The orange juice is superfluous, in my opinion, as it easily superimposes the taste of the mangoes; instead, liquidise the mango and add orange juice (or mango juice!) or water only when really necessary to reach the consistency of the sauce. Also add more lime juice – I think it’s just that contrast between a sweet, sticky, heavy rice and a fruity, light, and slightly sour sauce are rather desirable.
We left out the passion fruit and mint leaves entirely, but I’m sure they form a perfect addition.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food magazine, January 2010 edition. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 16th April 2010)Slight disappointment. I had expected something as good as the Vegetable Pilau I hade made a few months ago, but this dish tasted quite disbalanced. BF compared it to an orchestra that made sufficient noise (read: was tasty/aromatic enough), but that noise wasn't guided properly as to produce a nice harmonic tune.
Granted, we had to use tomato purée instead of real tomatoes because BF had secretly eaten them up (all of them!), and then (whisper) he actually used the whole double-sized tin (140g)!! Consequently, the dish tasted too much of tomato purée, a slightly sour taste, but also the taste of the curry (we used mild madras) or perhaps the tumeric was too strong. Halfway through the meal we had the idea to add some rasped coconut to balance the spices a little more, which worked a little.
Next time we´ll definitely use fresh tomatoes, even if that means going out to the store again, and cut the curry and tumeric by half, and then see how it goes. I do believe that the basic idea is very nice.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food magazine, July 2009 edition. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 16th April 2010)Basically this is a variation on my usual recipe of very basic Leek Tart, except that it features soft cheese with garlic and herbs and foregoes the egg-milk-cream mix. On the one hand I like the addition, on the other this might have been the reason why the crust didn’t become crisp at all (BF suggested a rating of only 3 stars at this point) – then again, an egg-milk-cream mix contains even more liquid, so we probably just didn’t give it enough time. It wasn’t quite enough for four, though.
We made this tart with (defrosted) mussels and shrimps instead of bacon, and the combination worked well, too.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food magazine, Oct. 2009 edition. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 16th April 2010)The good news: it's incredibly easy to prepare (just throw everything into a roasting tin and you're nearly done), it's beautiful and distinctly autumnal (it's the cover dish, for that matter), and BF and my guests last night loved it.
The bad news: I didn't. I was a bit disappointed because the flavours of the ingredients didn’t come together. What the sense of that? I thought cooking was the art of combining ingredients and creating something new. Instead, the chicken tasted like chicken (like a very tender chicken, though), the squash tasted like squash, the walnuts tasted like walnuts, and the sage, well, the sage was burnt and didn’t give off any flavour at all.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food magazine, Oct. 2009 edition. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 20th April 2010)BF prepared it and ate it while I only managed to get hold of the leftovers the next day (and believe me, reheated pasta with a cream sauce deteriorates enormously), so I'll have rely a bit on his judgement.
He liked it a lot, but he thought that it was just a little too creamy and not really moist enough; it's probably a good idea to save some pasta water next time, just in case. He also regretted that he couldn't do anything with the prawn shell, but then again most frozen prawns come without shells anyway. It definitely wasn't enough for 4 servings, it was rather 3 very light servings, or just a main dish for 2 (either that or he must have had a huge portion yesterday...).
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food series cookbook, 101 Store-cupboard Suppers. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 21st April 2010)This one was just okay. I wasn’t exactly wild about it (but then I’m not that much of a fan of fennel), and it didn’t help that the chicken ended up being a little dry.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in Olive magazine, August 2009 edition. And in the BBC Good Food magazine, July 2007 edition, apparently. Sneaky! |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 21st April 2010)Soooo delicious! In fact, this sorbet would have easily gained a 5 star rating if the consistency had been more like that of a true sorbet than that of slightly thawed snow. Still, the flavours nearly made you forget which is even more impressive as I was sceptic that cheap tinned fruit could be turned into anything delicious at all… Let me tell you, it can!
Edited to add:
We made the sorbet again, stirred it several times, and added an extra egg white - it was absolutely great! The extra egg white made the texture much finer. Definitely worth a 5-star rating!
I would recommend grating the zest as fine as you can instead of adding it in stripes - use a nutmeg grater for best results! Biting on a distinct piece of zest definitely isn't what you'd want in a sorbet.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food series cookbook, 101 Store-cupboard Suppers. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 21st April 2010)Just okay. It was quite bland, so the following day we doubled up the amount of ginger and garlic and marinated the tofu a little longer and yet it was somewhat bland. Roasting the sesames probably would have helped, too.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food series cookbook, 101 Store-cupboard Suppers. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 21st April 2010)Quickly prepared and very delicious, but I don’t think all went entirely well with the preparation. You’re supposed to mix the cream, sugar and lemon zest until it starts to thicken, then add the lemon juice and continue whisking the mixture until it thickens further but not too much or else you won’t be able to add the whipped egg whites – only that my mixture never became thick at all. Next time I’ll try whipping the cream first until semi-stiff before adding the sugar, lemon zest and juice.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the Olive: 101 Quick-fix Dishes cookbook. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 21st April 2010)Ah, another variant on the 'grilled salmon steak with vegetables and potato'-theme; see my Grilled Salmon with Watercress Cream Sauce for more on that. This one was extremely delicious - the best one so far!
It did have two deficits, though - you won't need 2 courgettes for 2 people, 1 or 1 1/2 are enough, and it took us more than 3 minutes to cook the courgettes, 20 minutes or so was more realistic. That's not really a problem, though, as long as you know it. The moment you've set the potatoes to cook, begin with slicing the courgettes and start frying them immediately. Then you'll have a great dinner ready in 20-25 min total cooking time.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the Olive: 101 Quick-fix Dishes cookbook.
|
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 21st April 2010)This dish was perfectly okay, just not very exciting. It did bother me a little that they cheated: anyone can make a one-pot pasta-dish with cooked penne (especially if you assume, like they did, that the pasta won't need reheating)!
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food series cookbook, 101 Store-cupboard Suppers. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 24th April 2010)It all started with a weird cultural problem. One of the ingredients are runner beans. I looked up runner beans on Wikipedia and found an entry on runner beans - brilliant! The only problem was that although it stated that this article covered the runner bean, also known as the scarlet runner bean, it said nowhere that there was also the common Green bean, known as runner bean in British English. I searched the whole city for scarlet runner beans, only to find out, once at home, that the BBC means green beans, haricots verts. Is that a problem of the BBC or of Wikipedia, or just my own? I bit of all of the above, I suppose.
So, what about the quiche, then? I must admit that I forgot to add the courgettes - blame it on the runner beans. And I was very sceptic about that bit of adding 300 ml milk (far too much!) and 25 g flour (ugh, don't want a floury tasting quiche) to the filling. But surprisingly, the filling was neither too liquid nor did it taste floury, on the contrary: it tasted surprisingly light. Do take care that you don't overcook the peas though - try adding them a few minutes later than the other veggies. And there's no need to use cherry tomatoes, normal tomatoes cut into eight pieces do just as well.
I made a Pâte Brisée, a French Shortcrust Pastry as a base, and it went together very well.
Edited 9 June 2015:
Restaurant quantities. I mean, really, 85 g each of courgette, beans and peas? Peas is easy, as are beans if you're able to buy them loose, but courgette? I therefore used a whole courgette (about 320 g), one package of green beans (200 g), two normal onions and 200 g cocktail tomatoes. To make up for that, I used 30 g flour, 350 ml milk and 3 eggs instead of 2. In other words: in terms of quantities, I didn't stick to the recipe at all.
The result did have a few flaws, which I'm afraid might be connected to what I just stated. The beans were slightly undercooked, and DH thought the eggs were still too liquid (I didn't). Because I used more vegetables than indicated, I also fried them for ten instead of five minutes, but that may not have been enough (I'll admit that they weren't soft yet at that stage, I thought that'd come while baking).
Still, I actually do enjoy this dish, and I suspect you can use it to throw in all your vegetable leftovers (broccoli would probably work really well). I also think you could probably combine it well with the Courgette, Chilli and Mint Pizzas, as you'll need less than a whole courgette for either of them, and the dishes are so different that it won't even be boring to eat courgette several days in a row. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 30th April 2010)We didn't follow the recipe to the letter. We made it with the shortcrust pastry from Gary Rhodes' New Classics instead of the block puff pastry - don't. Use block puff pastry, or try a different recipe for shortcrust pastry, if you must.
Then, while I was struggling with the pastry, my dear BF began preparing the filling, and before I knew what was going on he had added his 'special touch'. He thought 2 tablespoons of mascarpone and one of mustard couldn't be enough, so he just threw in an egg, and, as we wouldn't be able to fold the parmesan into the puff pastry he just threw that into the mix as well.
The result was quite nice, but slightly tasteless (where did the garlic go?), and it was definitely not enough. Between the two of us we finished up three quart of the tart (although admittedly we were really hungry), but I just can't see this as a main dish for 6. Made with puff pastry, the best tomatoes you can get and more garlic and thyme I expect that it can become a nice appetizer, but that's still a small way to go. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 8th May 2010)Basically, it is quite a nice dish and coud have received a 4 star rating, but it needed more seasoning as well as that special extra to make it a little more interesting tastewise, and some of the instructions just weren't quite right.
First of all, I've never come across a recipe for two persons that instructs you to use half an egg for one thing and half an egg for another - why just not double all the ingredients (should not be a problem technically in this case) and write the recipe for four servings?
Second, it's quite difficult to get the fish cakes right. Making four cakes from ca. 450g of mass will make you run the risk of getting too large fish cakes that are mushy on the inside and/or burnt on the outside. Make six to eight smaller, thinner cakes and you'll be fine. Also, fry them on a relatively low temperature, e.g. medium or medium-low, for at least several minutes, preferably without turning and tossing them the whole time.
Season them well, but most importantly, add something extra to the mayonnaise - a tiny bit of chilli, for example, or perhaps some coriander, to give it some extra zing. Something like the Chilli-Lime Mayo from this recipe (online version here) would work quite well.
And finally, serve it with extra vegetables, it'll be boring otherwise - good quality cherry tomatoes worked quite well for us.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the Olive: 101 Quick-fix Dishes cookbook. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 9th May 2010)The fish (we used tilapia as we couldn't get any rainbow trout) was slightly dry, and continued losing water even after we had placed it on the plate, making the rest of the food swim constantly in a layer of water. Bleh. Additionally, the fish itself tasted had hardly any taste and couldn't stand up to the very aromatic watercress sauce at all, so that was quite a mismatch.
I would suggest using a fish with a stronger proprietary taste, such as salmon (here we go again with the apparently classic combination of salmon and watercress: see also my Watercress Crème Fraîche Tart and Grilled Salmon with Watercress Cream Sauce). I would also try out adding some herbs or perhaps one or two lemon slices to the fish before steaming as described in the Trout with Ginger, Lime and Coriander or the Fish en Papillote, and open the parcels as soon as you take them out of the oven, don't allow condensate to develop.
Also, serve with a different side dish, shivers of iceberg salad without a proper salad dressing will be too bland.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the Olive: 101 Quick-fix Dishes cookbook. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 21st May 2010)Basically it was pretty nice - if there had not been the lemon. BF and I were sceptic from the start, not because we do not like the taste of lemons, but because the juice of a whole lemon seemed like far too much for that little bit of other ingredients. We started with the juice of only half a lemon - and oh boy, we tasted nothing but lemon in the end! Even worse: the combination of the saltiness and texture of the parmesan invoked some extremely unpleasant associations.
Nevertheless, I believe this recipe has potential and could even reach a 4 star rating - just limit the lemon juice to a few drops only, or even omit it completely. If necessary, you can replace it by oil and/or cooking water, both should be fine. Most of the lemon flavour should come from the zest, which has a stronger lemon taste anyway with the added benefit of not being sour.
Also, we used half the amount of pasta and shared the sauce between the two of us - just about enough. If you want to serve this dish to four persons, remember to double all ingredients except for the amount of pasta.
Crosspost. Exact the same recipe was also published in the BBC Good Food series cookbook, 101 Healthy Eats. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 28th June 2010)Well, it's not really a recipe, is it? You stuff a ready-made pizza base in the oven, throw some ingredients on top and that's it. Nothing special about it, is there?
Unless you change it. Purposely, or by accident, as we did. We exchanged the ricotta (sold out) for cottage cheese and pizza bases (didn't know where they hid) for pita breads. Preheat the oven to 250°C, cut the pita breads into halves, scatter and spread all the ingredients on top in one go, grill for just five minutes and you're meal is done, and quite crispy and delicious, too. Great idea for parties, though in that case you should cut the each pita bread in eight pieces to get real fingerfood. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 1st July 2010)Nice but not particularly mind-blowing. It needs a lot more spices than specified (try using the double amount), and I felt that the sauce was too much liquid too - either cut back on the amount of liquid added, or try to make the sauce thicker one way or other.
Edited to add:
It also tastes nice cold, especially on such hot days as these. Definitely double the amount of spices and add some salt.
Edited 7 January 2015:
I made this again and used the double amount of spices - much better already, but still not particularly impressive. But even so, it is so easy to make that I guess it will end up being a standard on our weekday dinner menu. I forgot to add less liquid, but solved that by using the cooking liquid to cook the couscous, which works quite nicely.
I would also suggest changing the ratio of the vegetables - I don't think courgette/zucchini works particularly well in this dish, though I'm not quite sure substituting an aubergine for one of the courgettes would make it any better. Definitely add more raisins, perhaps one or two bell peppers, and possibly more chickpeas?
Upgraded from a 3 to a 4 star rating. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 4th July 2010)Very delicious, and the apricots are definitely a eye-catcher, BUT there were a few slight issues and one major fail.
As so often, the recipe calls for the juice of one lemon to be added. I added the juice of a quart lemon (approximately), and it ended up being sour. My advice would be to add no lemon at all but to wait right until the end and then taste it - and if you then think you could do with a little lemon, add some, carefully.
Other points to watch out for: the freshly grated ginger might burn, add extra oil and stir to prevent that, and the chicken is prone to become dry, as so often with similar recipes, so don't cook it longer than absolutely necessary.
But what I really didn't understand: First, you need to add ten ready-to-eat apricots. Next, you're asked to serve it with a handful of pomegranate seeds. Now in which country are apricots and pomegranates available in the same season? Really, they should have known better than this! |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 14th July 2010)The potatoes were undercooked, the herbs and spices hardly noticeable, and the whole thing just didn't combine together well. A very ill conceived recipe.
Let's start with the potatoes. I was aware that this could happen, and sliced them very very thinly - ca. 2mm. Additionally, I boiled them for several minutes instead of draining them immedeately. You can probably cook them for 8-10 minutes without worrying. However, even if they had been cooked well, it would have been a shame that they were wet, being covered in white wine. I would have wished them to become crisp chips, baked in olive with sea salt and rosemary!
Then the spices. As I said, you hardly tasted them. A tiny bit of garlic here, one bite with a hint of saffron there... not what I would have expected. But had they been stronger it probably wouldn't have helped as the combination of flavours was just too much. Fish with white wine and saffron - yes, I get that. Fish with lime and coriander - good idea too. Tomatoes with saffron, fish/seafood and, err, rice - Paella. But fish with all of the above? And then I'm not yet even mentioning the pine nuts (which I omitted anyway). And if this weren't bad enough - even if the ingredients would have worked together, if they had been strong enough to be tasted then the sheer mass of them would have eliminated any taste of fish.
The fish in itself was fairly nice (though slightly bland if a fish can ever be bland), but I'm afraid that was a happy coincidence.
PS: Oh, and the pancetta... white wine, coriander, tomatoes, saffron, pancetta, lime, pine nuts... hmm... |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 23rd July 2010)Very delicious! A very mild flavour, mainly due to the yoghurt, and very tender. Just perfect for poultry. We used masala spices instead of Masala paste, and it worked very well. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 23rd July 2010)Reminded me very very much of the Baked Vegetables with an Aubergine Sauce from Nigel Slater's Tender, though neither as delicious nor as well-thought through.
Both recipes instruct you to bake vegetables in the oven and add harissa, cumin and nuts half-way through. Slater accompanied this with a wonderful aubergine dip that would have been a good addition to this recipe, too.
Furthermore, in this recipe they suggested bite-sized pices of butternut squash and red and yellow peppers for the same amount of time - of course the butternut squash wasn't ready yet when the peppers were. Additionally, they didn't mention anything about splashing a bit of oil on top, something that I've noticed makes the veggies cook much better.
On the other hand I have to admit that I couldn't find any harissa and I didn't have the time nor the recipe at hand to make harissa myself, like I did the last time. So we just followed a recipe found on the internet and used the main ingredients without really making harissa - the real harissa last time was much better. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 20th August 2010)Very delicious, though it could have been better. First of all, cooking time is more something like 1 hour 20 minutes instead of 40 minutes. We replaced doubled creme (not available here) with a mix of single cream and mascarpone. I worried about the pasta not cooking because it wasn't covered in sauce, but this turned out fine (though we added extra cream).
There were no instructions on how to cut the fennel (if it was supposed to be cut at all), so we just sliced it. In the end, fennel proved to be the weak point. Although the dish was delicious, the fennel was still a bit too hard for my liking, and I would suggest cutting up the fennel into small cubes or stripes to make it cook faster and to be able to spread it easier. Furthermore, there was too much of it too - or rather not enough of everything else, as it didn't feed four persons anyway.
On the positive side, although cooking time is fairly long, relatively little time is needed for preparation, especially for a lasagna. And, as I said, it was delicious, and with the above changes it could make a great dish. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 6th October 2010)This may look like your usual pasta-with-salmon-wednesday-night dish, but I learnt a few lessons from it. One, for some reason I never used Parmesan (though I fried chopped onions instead), and I loved the idea of melting the parmesan in the cream to make a really cheesy sauce. Two, often I don't used fresh herbs as it's simply too expensive to buy them and then use them just as garnish. In this recipe, the basil is so much more than just garnish, it really adds something to it. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 11th February 2011)Very delicious, very spicy, and very easy to prepare, once you have your harissa paste ready (I used a home made one).
I used less tomato passata, for the simple reason that I only had 500ml containers and it seemed silly to open a second container for just another 200ml - and I'm glad I didn't. The consistency was nice, not too dry, and the taste of the tomatoes would have overpowered everything else (well, perhaps it wasn't a good quality passata, it smelled slightly artificial). For some more texture you could add the pumpkin a little later and make sure it doesn't get too soft.
Edited 6 March 2013:
We made this dish again last night, and it was such a difference! We used the full amount of tomato passata asked for; we used two cans of chickpeas instead of one (we weren't sure if '400g can chickpeas' refers to the weight of the can including liquid or just the chickpeas alone), we used a small pumpkin whereas normally I often use a butternut squash instead, and I might have forgotten to add the ground cumin.
The result was a mediocre, throw-random-ingredients-together dish, and I was very surprised to see we had originally given it 5 stars! I hope we will be able to try this again soon.
Edited 26 February 2014:
We made this again, this time using the quantities I used the first time. The resulting dish was rather mediocre - not too bad, except for the tomato sauce that I think was too thick and concentrated, and had turned into a kind of ketchup - not very pleasant. Other than that it was okay; I liked that it was actually quite easy to prepare. I wonder if things were different if you used fresh tomatoes instead of passata.
Quite similar to this dish of Indian Pumpkin and Chickpeas with Raisins and Almonds. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 14th June 2011)Really delicious! We slightly adapted the recipe as we had bought lamb joint instead of shoulder, and therefore followed the instructions of our butcher regarding the cooking instructions. Also, we ran out of ground cumin, and as cumin is difficult to grind we just used whole cumin instead. Everything worked well, the meat was really tender and the sauce very delicious!
We ended up serving the pomegranates scattered on top of the meat, not on the salad, that seemed to work bettter. We served the lamb with a slightly adapted version of Pilau from Noshe Djan, an excellent combination! |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 24th July 2011)Really, really delicious! Real comfort food too, and really easy! What's not to love about it?
You can also barbecue these wings, or grill them in a grill pan, which is what we might do tomorrow. Also, we only let them marinate for one hour, so another reason to leave part of the wings in the marinade for as long as possible and prepare them tomorrow.
We served this with Beetroot with Yoghurt, a good combination and a good choice for a Middle Eastern side dish!
Edited 10 Sept. 2012:
We made this again and served it as part of a mezze platter together with Beetroot with Yoghurt, Saffron Cauliflower, Coconut Prawn Skewers and some Turkish flatbread, and it was great!
The chicken wings tasted very different this time, though - we should have used more honey, more salt, less lemon juice, and more cumin. Nevertheless, it was a great and relaxed meal. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 24th July 2011)Nice. I'm not entirely sure the sugar (syrup) was necessary. In any case, don't just add sugar, won't work. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 24th August 2011)DB enjoyed this salad very much! He had a few minor points of critique, such as that the ginger wasn’t strong enough (I might not have added the whole amount because I thought it would be too much – it’s not, go for it!), and that it tasted slightly watery – try to let the veggies dry as much as possible.
We were both surprised that the combination of lentils and the other veggies worked so well with this Asian-inspired dressing of garlic, soy sauce and sesame oil, but it did, especially with the lentils and the sugar snaps. We substituted the soy beans for broad beans which worked very well.
I had my difficulties with getting the timing right for cooking the veggies – if you’re unsure about, cook them separately, much of the success of this salad will depend on whether the veggies are still crisp and al dente. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 24th September 2011)I only made part of this recipe, the (very impressive looking) topping, and used the recipe of a friend for the rest of the cake. And as I had quite some problems with the instructions for the topping, I was actually quite glad I could rely on my recipe for the rest of the cake.
The biggest problem was that you're supposed to heat 200g sugar and juice of one lemon in a saucepan until the sugar just begins to caramelise. However, given the quantities, in reality the sugar will never caramelise, only dissolve in the juice. I ended up doing the whole thing again, only this time adding only a few drops every now and then, adding the rest of the juice only once the sugar did begin to caramelise, and this worked so much better!
However, if, as instructed, you start out with this step and only after that begin to peel and slice the lemons, you might run into trouble again, as you will be busy for a while and the caramel will cool down and harden; luckily not too much in my case, but why risk it? It's so easy to just turn around the order in which you're doing things.
Then the caramel started leaking out of the springform tin I was using; not so bad while I was preparing the batter, but a lot worse while it was in the oven - I was glad I had placed a baking tray below, just in case. Just something you should realise, use another type of tin if you can.
Last, in the end I wasn't able to see the lemon slices at all - which for me had been the whole reason to make the topping. Perhaps it would help to not let the sugar caramelise at all (mine was a light brown before and after baking), but it would probably work even better if you used oranges (or clementines for size) or blood oranges instead. That said, even if invisible the topping was very delicious on top of an excellent cake, which is whyI'll give it 3 stars.
I had to use double the recipe my friend gave me to be able to fill the 23cm springform tin, but apart from longer baking times this wasn't a problem at all.
Served together with Nigels Slater's Chocolate Brownies, a perfect combination of sweet and sweet-sour, chocolate and fruit.
|
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 29th September 2011)Very simple. I actually quite liked it, though it wasn't really special, but DB thought it was too sweet, and didn't like the sweetness with the beans. Both of us also agreed that the sauce was too liquid, and that it was difficult to eat the pecans together with the beans. However, I liked the crunch of the nuts with the beans.
We served this with Roast Pork with Apples and Mustard, which was a good choice in a way because I just imagined that maple being part of the pork dish - in that sense, it complemented one another very well. It probaly would have been maple-overkill in combination with my favourite pork-apple-dish, Sticky Maple Pork with Apples, but you still could just add some pecans, perhaps with a bit of butter and salt. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 29th September 2011)It's not exactly the first dish with Pork and Apples (and Mustard!) I've been making; and of all four, this one included, three are from the BBC (surprise, surprise!). And it's really not that different.
One important difference was the quantity of liquid added in relation to what it should be as a result - you don't need the 200ml stock at all. It's probably enough to just add the mustard and crème fraîche, carefully heating both (be careful with the crème fraîche to prevent it from shifting!), perhaps add a few spoonfuls of water and that's it. Additionally, if you use that much iquid, you tend to overcook the pork because you might hope that the sauce will thicken if you cook it just a bit longer - nope, it won't.
Of all previous versions (Pork and Apple Braise, Normandic Skewers and Sticky Maple Pork with Apples), I definitely most enjoyed the Sticky Maple Pork.
We served this with Maple Pecan Beans - a good combination, in a way, because the maple combined very well with the combination of apples, pork, mustard and sage (and pecans), but less so with the beans. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 7th October 2011)DB had this as a lunch box salad this week, and he didn't really get the idea behind it. On one hand you had the crunchy, uncooked cauliflower, on the other the strong blue cheese; neither of the two combined with the other nor took up any of the dressing. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 16th November 2012)Hmm. I wasn't really convinced. I'll admit I'm not a fan of chocolate fondants - I'd rather have chocolate mousse, chocolate ice cream or a brownie. But apart from that - the dessert tasted very heavy, but it wasn't very rich in flavour. Even though we had used a good quality chocolate, it tasted like pretty cheap stuff.
Additionally, we noticed too late that the recipe yields 9 fondants (why 9?) - by then, we had prepared half a recipe and filled 2 1/2 moulds with the resulting mixture. This resulted in much longer baking times (15 minutes +), which, again, is something we only figured out later. Not the best premises.
We served it with cranberry sauce, which was a good choice. Caramel sauce and sweet ice cream only would have added even more sugar. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 18th November 2012)I was worried the souffle would turn out dry, but it was really, nice, very cheesy and not dry at all. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 4th April 2013)Nice, but not particularly impressive. We substituted watercress with rocket, and added a little less avocado than required. It was interesting in that it combined all kinds of different flavours/textures, sharp and bitter and sour and creamy flavours (rocket/watercress and chicory and lime and avocado), but that also meant that you were constantly switching between these flavours, as opposed to them having melted into one another. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 14th April 2013)We only made the panna cotta (to go with this Mango Sorbet), and it was very good! Very creamy and with a distinct coconut flavour. DH thought the coconut flavour could have been a little stronger, which I don't think is really necessary. We both agreed however that it contained too much gelatine, though that isn't this recipe's fault as we followed the package instructions. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 5th November 2013)Very nice, though to be honest you didn't taste the vodka - you might just as well just fry the chorizo before serving them.
Served with Pears in Parma Ham as an appetizer.
Edited 8 November 2013:
We had the rest of the chorizo today and only fried it - it ended up being hard and crisp, as opposed to the softer chorizo from a few days ago. So apparently even if the vodka does not impart a lot of flavour, it does help in keeping the chorizo soft, if that's what you like. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 5th November 2013)Hmm. The shortcrust pastry was very weird, very wet and sticky - no wonder, it contained not only a whole egg but also an additional egg yolk. That made it really difficult to handle, even after cooling it in the fridge for several hours. In the end, I used a trick: I often roll out pastry between two sheets of parchment paper. I did that, removed one sheet, lined the tart tin with the pastry and left the other sheet in place - after all, it had to be blind baked with parchment paper and baking beans, right?
Unfortunately, though, the pastry baked well at the edges but stayed moist in the middle; because I didn't want to end up with an undercooked pastry, I pre-baked the pastry a lot longer than instructed, and once I baked the tart with quince filling, crumble and all, I ended up with burnt edges.
Also, it didn't help that I used a different crumble. I had forgotten to buy rolled oats, and I happened to have a one third quantity of Ottolenghi's crumble (which I of course used thawed). The problem is that this crumble needs an hour to be baked; I don't know how much time the crumble from this recipe would have needed (probably less, given the short baking time in this recipe), but that in any case didn't help.
Looking back, it would have been better remove the second sheet as well, flour it again and then return it, so that the pastry would stick less and hopefully bake more evenly. Also, given that the quince filling is already cooked anyway, it's a lot easier to just fully bake the pastry, have your quince filling ready, bake the crumble on a baking tray and then just assemble while everything is hot. Yes, that might be cheating, but who cares (and who would notice)? Additionally, the crust won't get soggy either!
The flavour of the pastry, once it was baked, was really nice, so I was hopeful it would all be worth the hassle. Unfortunately, though, I didn't actually taste the pastry at all once the quince filling was added. The quince filling was very nice and is something I might consider making again. I didn't add the cornstarch, but I will probably do that next time as the filling ended up being just a tad too liquid. DH even suggested poaching the quinces like in this recipe (with or without the rose water) and using them like apples in apple pie. I think the quince does need some strong flavours, so ground nuts or wholemeal flour will be a good idea (hmm, what if you omit the eggs or at least the egg yolk, and replace the ground almonds with ground hazelnuts?).
Also, as nice as this tart was, but be warned that you will spend a long time in the kitchen.
Served for tea with Scones and Walnut Cake with Coffee Syrup - all of them very nice, but the Quince Crumble Tart actually felt more like a dessert than a tea time treat. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 5th November 2013)Very nice recipe! I used 2:1 preserving sugar, meaning I used 1 part sugar and 2.2 parts quince juice; I also made one half with a little rosewater, and the other half without. I really enjoyed the addition of the rosewater, I will do that again. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 5th November 2013)Very nice! As with the Quince and Rosewater Jelly, I used 2:1 preserving sugar, meaning I used 1 part sugar and 2.2 parts quince pulp. I cooked it for the whole 45 min on low heat, stirring constantly, but yet it ended up being burnt at the bottom of the pan - luckily not something you notice in the membrillo (be careful not to scrape the bottom).
I thought the instructions on how long you really need to cook the membrillo (what I like to call 'the Moses test' - it even looked like a red sea!) were still relatively vague. My membrillo ended up being relatively soft, compared to that of my MIL, but apparently mine is more like the membrillo you can buy at shops (not that I would know). Also, my MIL used more sugar, which made her membrillo sweeter (obviously), but I think that also influences how hard the membrillo will get (or how long it takes to get there).
Last, be careful: hot membrillo is hostile and will hiss and spit at you, I have several blisters to attest to that. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 5th January 2015)I was about to make the Smoked Haddock Chowder, when I realised it was an awful lot like Cullen Skink, which we had dubbed 'liquid fish pie'. So I chose to make this chowder instead. This chowder, then again, is a lot like Salmon Chowder with Whisky - I guess at some point every dish will remind you of some other dish you once had, right?
It's a very, pretty basic chowder, one you can whip up quick enough for a midweek dinner and doesn't require any excursions to the fish monger. DH actually prefers the Salmon Chowder, as he thinks that one has a little more flavour (probably the addition of the tomato), but what I enjoy about this one is the lemony flavour and the fact that it contains two kinds of fish (salmon and, in our case, pangasius), and that the fish didn't end up being dry, which it always does in the Salmon Chowder.
However, it actually took about 10-12 min until the fish was cooked instead of the 3-4 minutes mentioned in the recipe - I guess this really depends on how large your chunks of fish are. The recipe also doesn't mention what type of potato you should use - I used floury ones. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 16th January 2016)These held together well (in contrast to our last attempt at fish cakes), but the portion sizes were quite small - it looked more like a large appetizer or a small lunch than a main dish. It also could use a bit more potato - fish cakes with that much fish are of course a treat, but if that's all you serve, it's a lot of fish and little else (you could, of course, also just serve it with potatoes on the side). All in all, though, I'm beginning to think that making fish cakes is a small art in itself, and that it doesn't consist of adding I don't know how many special ingredients, but of getting the consistency right, and being able to fry without them falling apart, or getting burnt, or both.
The sauce, by the way, wasn't really necessary, and even if, a simpler sauce would have done as well. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 27th January 2016)It wasn't too bad, but it wasn't particularly impressive either. And what else can you expect of pasta, a can of tomatoes and some flavouring?
I didn't dare cook the pasta in the sauce directly - I cannot see how that would work, as you'd need to add a whole litre of stock to the sauce - and then you'll end up with what, tomato soup? So I omitted the stock and cooked the pasta seperately.
Fine for a weekday dinner in a really busy week, but otherwise I wouldn't bother. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 31st January 2016)Very nice! I've made tortilla once before, years ago, and it didn't work out that well. It was different this time, it simply worked well. I did my best, however, to slice the potatoes very thin, and I guess that covering them helps as well. We didn't serve it with the bread with tomato and garlic, as suggested (we simply made oven-roast tomatoes instead), so the tortilla itself could have used a bit more garlic - maybe not necessary if you do add the bread.
I though it was a bit on the small side for four persons as a main dish - add an extra side dish, or make a little more. I also thought that the potato-to-egg-ratio could have been a little more favourable towards the potatoes - using, say, 600g potatoes probably solves both problems in one go. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 31st January 2016)Similar to the (original) Cranachan we made a year and a half ago, and about just as good.
Again, you need to be really careful with the oats - I let them burn on my first attempt, but luckily it's easy to just toss them out and start again. Remembering the other recipe, I didn't use the cheap clear, runny honey we had, but our good-quality heather honey, and that really made a difference (we used a cheap whisly, however - now I'm curious how it'd taste with a, say, earthy Tallisker).
I was surprised to see that you were supposed to mix the oatmeal through the cream, as I remembered that the other recipe differed in this respect - in the end that didn't matter, both versions are nice. And I noticed that this version used a mixture of single cream and Greek yoghurt (which we substituted with Quark), not solely double cream.
We actually used 2 oranges and 2 blood oranges (would have used 4 blood oranges if we had had them). I could actually see this recipe work with quite a number of fruits. For some reason, pomegranate is the very first that comes to my mind; mango would probably work as well.
Edited 20 March 2016:
I made this again, though this time I mixed all ingredients (except for the oranges and some of the oats) a few hours in advance instead of just moments before serving - and the flavours just disappeared! I could hardly taste any whisky, nor honey nor anything else! I think they used their time to meld into one big flavour, while I prefer to taste them seperately. So whip the cream beforehand, but assemble everything a la minute. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 20th March 2016)Very nice, and quite simple! Easy enough to make it a weeknight staple, but tasty enough for guests, too! My only quibbles are that I think that 5 dried apricots is a little stingy, and that all in all, the dish itself isn't really generous either - we used 600g instead of 500g lamb and served it with Zahlouk and couscous, and it was just barely enough! Make sure you make about 1.5-2x the amount if you expect hungry eaters.
Also, I am considering trying this with beef instead of lamb - lamb is just too expensive around here. Will probably work, even though it'll need to braise a little longer.
Edited the next day:
Good god, I'm such an idiot! The recipe serves two only, so no wonder it was a little meager. The thing is - I knew, which is why I bought 600 g of lamb, as opposed to just 250 g, but apparently, I forgot that immediately again!
That said, for four servings, I'd definitely double or even double-and-a-half the amount of meat and apricots, but I'm not sure the rest of the ingredients need to be doubled - we quite liked it the way it was. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 22nd March 2016)WHY didn't I read the comments? The finished dish itself was good and definitely has potential, but the recipe just didn't work! The thing is - you don't add any proper liquid. None. At all. Granted, the puréed tomatoes are slightly liquid, but other than that? Not at all enough to either cook the lentils nor the broccoli. I had the recipe printed (without comments, of course) and at a certain point I started adding glugs of water. Once I read the comments, I added whole glasses of water.
If making again (and I'm planning on making this again), I will probably indeed double the spices (it tastes very spicy in the beginning, but definitely mellows down once you add the broccoli, chickpeas and spinach!), use coconut cream and a can of coconut milk (with another one as backup), and I might actually also use sweet potatoes, I like the idea. Pumpkin would probably also work. Or add both (broccoli and pumpkin)!
Edited 18 July 2017:
I've made this a few times since, and with the changes described above (excl. the sweet potato/pumpkin), it makes a decent weeknight dinner.
I used two large sweet potatoes this time, pressure-steamed and added at the very end; at the very last moment I realized that it would probably be best to use them as a substitute for the chickpeas. As usual, I forgot to add the sesame and cashew; I also forgot the spinach. DH thought something was missing, and it might well have been the cashews. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 22nd April 2016)Very, very nice in taste, BUT:
- we made half a recipe as a side dish for the two of us (three including baby, but normally that doesn't really matter), and it wasn't enough at all! How is a whole recipe supposed to be enough for 4 persons as a main?
- we omitted the ham, and thought the gratin (other than the cheese crust) wasn't salty enough. Next time I'd either add salt or bacon.
- I only remembered to add the cheese once I took off the aluminium foil; which was useful, in a way, as I was able to spoon the stock mixture over the potatoes one last time. Once I had added the cheese, spooning liquid over the potatoes doesn't really work as you'd destroy your cheese crust.
- the online recipe only requires a 'carton double cream', without specifying which size carton. I image-googled a carton double cream and assumed that they meant a 300 ml carton; I only now read in the comments that the original printed recipes calls for a 142/150 ml carton. I might try it with less cream next time, but there is a danger that the potatoes will then not be submerged in liquid and therefore not cook as well as they should (see point above re: spooning over liquid).
- next time I'd definitely use double the amount of leeks and garlic
|
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 22nd May 2016)We used beef mince instead of lamb (does that make it a Milkmaid's Pie?), and about 2/3 of a can of tomatoes, as I had run out of tomato concentrate. We also served it as 'Deconstructed Shepherd's Pie' tonight, as I was in a rush and didn't have the time to bake it in the oven - as all ingredients were already cooked through, why not?
The result was delicious, but a little flat - unsurprisingly, if you've read the comments below the recipe. We ate half today and will eat the other half tomorrow, properly baked as it should be, with lots of cheese added, we'll see if that makes a difference.
Edited later on:
Yes, it does.
Edited sometime in autumn 2016:
Don't make the potato purée according to that recipe - it uses way too much butter! Just make it the way you always make it. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 16th October 2016)I made this a couple of weeks ago and never really had the time to review it properly, so my memory is a little hazy. I think I omitted the stock cube, as tomato purée and Worcestershire sauce already contains more than enough salt, and added a few more carrots and celery sticks - though next time I'd only add more carrots, not also celery sticks (other additional root vegetables might work well, though). The result was fine, although you should remember to stir it once a while to make sure everything is evenly covered. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 10th November 2017)It's nice when done well, but it's definitely not easy (not in the meaning of 'not complex'), and it contains several mistakes.
1. Both the potatoes and the aubergines need to be fully cooked. Baking the moussaka for 10 min will only allow the cheese to melt, not cook the vegetables. Grilling the aubergines (esp. without oil on them) won't cook them; it'll only get them partially charred (a.k.a. burnt). I grilled one aubergine, and baked the second one with a little olive oil in the oven, 20 min at 175 degrees C - much better (and less work!). The potatoes need to be fully cooked and cut into thin slices (5 mm max) if you want to have any chance of having more than one layer (I used 5 large-ish potatoes and barely managed two layers in two small casseroles).
2. If you want to end with a layer of aubergine, don't specify to start with a layer of potato, then aubergine, then meat sauce.
I didn't have mixed spice, so I used 1/4 tsp cinnamon, allspice and nutmeg each, and about 1/8 tsp each of coriander, cloves and ginger (all of them ground). I forgot to add the creme fraiche, but we just added it at the table, which was nice as well. I do like that you can prepare this dish in advance and only need to pop it into the oven for 10 min (though you'll probably need more than that when taken straight from the fridge).
|
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 17th March 2018)Just saw that I've never reviewed this recipe! Nice dish, though we've never made the celeriac mash, just the braised beef. |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 9th June 2018) |
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 9th September 2018)This was awful, oily, and using bad technique. I would have expected this to be stir-fried and steamed (because why else would you use a wok?), and 'medium heat' does not work in that context. Also, you'll add a total of 4 tbsps of oil - way too much! And last, don't heat sesame oil, and don't use 2 tbsps of it.
Served alongside Braised Pork with Plums - wonderful!
|
| From: BBC Good Food (reviewed 9th September 2018)Very easy, and fantastic in taste! We used spare ribs, as this was what our butcher recommended, and it was very delicious, albeit heavy in fat (obviously). I omitted the star anise and used 9 damson plums, and the dish could have used much more plums; I'm pretty sure you could also make this with prunes.
Served with rice and Sesame Pak Choi - while pak choi goed really well with the pork, the execution of that dish was awful. |
| From: BBC Olive (reviewed 22nd November 2009)This one was just okay. I wasn’t exactly wild about it (but then I’m not that much of a fan of fennel), and it didn’t help that the chicken ended up being a little dry.
Crosspost. I found out that the exact the same recipe was published online. I crossposted my review here. |
| From: BBC Olive (reviewed 22nd November 2009)Just plain ugh. VERY strange combination of flavours. Too strange, actually, for my taste. The Pepperonata was far too sweet to combine well. |
| From: BBC Olive (reviewed 22nd November 2009)Very sophisticated ten minute (ehm, okay, 15 minute) pizzas. I absolutely loved the taste, it was fresh, varied, and it definitely showed that you can combine mozzarella with more than tomato and basil.
Our naan-bread was quite soggy, though. I liked it, the same way I I like a Domino's pizza once in a while. But I can also imagine that some might prefer something more crunchy. Baked/grilled baguette might be the solution here, and also makes it possible to serve it as finger food at your next party.
Beware that the quantities of the ingredients aren't completely right – we used only one instead of two courgettes and had some courgette leftovers, while the mozzarella was just enough. So that's a four star rating instead of five...
Edited to add:
The recipe is available online here. You can also review it here. |
| From: BBC Olive (reviewed 24th October 2010)Quite nice, but can be improved upon. It's very heavy, slightly bitter (though that might be due to the very dark chocolate), and the Earl Grey tea was hardly noticeable (that is to say: DB tasted it, I didn't) even though I already used double the amount of tea. I will probably make it again tomorrow with stronger (and perhaps even more) tea, and with double the amount of eggs, just to see if it makes it any lighter (today, I used 100g chocolate for 2 eggs, always one egg per person). I might even try Lapsang Souchong instead of Earl Grey. I'll try to get other chocolate, too - the one I used today had cocoa nibs in it and didn't really become liquid when I melted it.
We didn't make the Orange Blossom Cream, I hope to try it tomorrow. I could imagine using rose water instead of orange flower water - orange flower water always makes me think of soap!
Edited one day later to add:
As announced, I made this recipe again, albeit, for testing reasons, only half the recipe with a quarter of the given amount of ('normal' dark) chocolate (50g chocolate for 2 eggs). Additionally, I added 2 teaspoons of sugar, and whipped it together with the egg yolks until they were nearly white, at least five minutes. You could really see how the volume of the egg yolks expanded!
Unfortunately, once I added the chocolate, this effect seemed to be gone again. I am thinking whether it might have been better not to use a kitchen machine once you've added the chocolate. In any case, don't use one once you add the egg whites!
The resulting chocolate mousse was wonderfully light but tasted slightly eggy and not very chocolatey. Perhaps I should aim for an egg-chocolate ratio somewhere in between...
PS: Still didn't taste any Earl Grey... I used Earl Grey again because I was afraid the smokey taste of Lapsang could be too strong, but now... Alternatively, coffee would probably work, or orange zest, or mint, or rose water (?)...
Edited another three days later to add:
I used 75g chocolate per 2 eggs and served them in cute little cups to my guests. To my great surprise, the mousse was just as heavy as the first version! Very delicious, though, just not quite what I had expected given my experiments during the days before..
Tastewise, I ignored the Earl Grey and added some cardamom (nice spice!) and a pinch of salt to make the flavour come out more. I was planning to serve it with rosemary cream, but in the end I didn't. |
| From: BBC Olive (reviewed 25th October 2010)Very delicious! I used caster sugar instead of white sugar (actually, nothing specific was suggested which made me think they meant white one), and it really made it taste like Caipirinha while at the same time you could definitely taste the berries. It tasted slightly watery, which might have been due to my poor ice-crushing techniques (a few large chunks with lots of 'snow'); and at the same time, the alcohol tasted pretty strong, although that passed quickly :)
You might try cheating by adding some berry juice or sirup to get more flavour, though if you choose sirup don't forget to omit the sugar. |
| From: BBC recipes (reviewed 18th June 2014)Yes, I do realize that Chilli con Carne isn't really Mexican, but TexMex at best, but it was a nice change from the empanadas and Baleadas we've had during the last few days (I seem to be thinking that most of the Central and South American countries will drop out in the group stage - Mexico already proved me wrong last night!).
Anyway, about this dish: I enjoyed it. I made a few changes, using about 450 g peeled and chopped tomatoes instead of the tomato concentrate and the passata, and slightly more beans (500 g instead of 400 g).
I had no idea how much '2 squares 70% dark chocolate, grated' was supposed to be - I know chocolate bars where that could be anything from 10 g to 100 g. Because years ago I made a chocolate-based main dish that went horribly wrong, I decided to start out with just a little, about 10 g, and then take it from there. It was fascinating to notice that even that little completely changed the flavour of the dish, making it a lot more earthy, and quite unexpected (with some eating experience you'll probably know what to expect if a dish contains onions, carrots, beef, beans - add chocolate to that equation and it will turn it into something completely different).
Edited 18. January 2016:
I used 1/2 tsp chilli and 1/2 tsp hot paprika, and it turned out quite a bit hotter than I expected. Luckily, kiddo (at 10.5 months) didn't seem to mind at all! He had a bit of a problem with the green pepper and some pieces of carrot as he wasn't able to chew them yet, but other than that this dish worked surprisingly well. Served with white rice for the adults, and potato-fennel mash for the little guy. We omitted the chocolate and the sour cream, mainly because that ended up on the second page of the recipe and I had stopped reading at that point. |
| From: BBC recipes (reviewed 10th December 2014)Extremely simple, extremely quick, and quite delicious! I'm only not very sure if they really tasted 100% like what shortbread is supposed to taste - they actually rather reminded me of normal butter cookies.
Some of them I sprinkled with lavender sugar instead of normal caster sugar, which was a nice accent, but not really noticeable. I guess I would have to replace some of the caster sugar in the dough with lavender sugar as well to get a more distinct lavender flavour. |
| From: BBC recipes (reviewed 1st February 2015)Basically, this is a recipe for braised cabbage, with a serving suggestion of grilled salmon - really, there's not much the recipe says about the salmon. The braised Savoy cabbage, however, was really nice, and I'm especially glad I found this recipe as I don't have a lot of recipes for Savoy cabbage.
I used four slices of bacon as English bacon rashers are usually way thicker than Dutch ones, and I might use 6 next time. I used half a large Savoy cabbage, shredded, and also braised it quite a while longer, about 17 min, but I guess that depends on how al dente you want your cabbage to be. When I wanted to add the cabbage, I noticed that all the butter had already been soaked up by the bacon and onions - don't be afraid to add another knob of butter before you add the cabbage, it'll need it. The vinaigrette was too strong, too dominating for my taste; I thought it was too mustardy and also a little too sour; next time, I would add a little oil (or perhaps even melted butter?), mainly to make it thinner. That said, the cabbage is just as nice without vinaigrette.
Served with plain rice as I forgot to buy potatoes - something like roast potatoes, or maybe boiled new potatoes might go nicely with this dish.
Edited 2 August 2015:
We used a pointed green/white cabbage as we couldn't get a savoy cabbage - savoy cabbage is so much nicer! |
| From: BBC recipes (reviewed 2nd February 2015)Quite nice and very easy! I used only six small potatoes for the two of us to serve with Grilled Salmon, Braised Cabbage with Bacon and Onions, though five probably would have been enough as well. I also used one garlic clove, and dried tarragon instead of fresh rosemary as I felt that tarragon would go better with the Savoy cabbage and the salmon. And it did! I really liked the flavour of the potatoes, especially the garlic.
Unfortunately, though, the potatoes didn't get as crisp as I would have hoped, and definitely not as crisp as my usual recipe of Oven Fried Potatoes with Oregano and Lemon from The Olive and the Caper. I wonder if it had made a difference if I had used floury instead of waxy poatoes. |
| Very nice orange cake. The only problem was that the cake didn’t soak up the juices very well, and I didn’t have a lot of patience to splash a little juice on in every so many minutes. It ended up being quite dry, though I am sure that if you succeed with soaking, it’ll be quite nice (I actually think I succeeded the first time I made this, some fifteen years ago, which is why I kept on returning to this recipe). |