hipcook's Reviews
260 recipes reviewed. Showing 51 to 100Sort by: Book Title 
| Date | Rating | Recipe Title
The New Chesapeake Kitchen
By John Shields, David W. Harp
Johns Hopkins University Press - 2018
Frankly, I still don't love rhubarb. But I do like the fact that the rhubarb puree mixes with the uncooked strawberries in a way that preserves the fresh taste and texture of both, and doesn't go gloppy or overly sweet. The shortcakes are definitely a hit.
useful (0)
Most of my ratatouille recipes are built in a skillet or pot. In this one, the vegetables are roasted first and then covered with tomato sauce. The result is that the eggplants, peppers and zucchini hold their shape and individual flavors better.
We just ate it as a side dish; serving over pasta or rice would also be nice.
useful (0)
Pleasant little snack. The orange flavor comes through more than I'd expected and I like the sweet instead of savory take. It did take 4 minutes longer in my oven than the recipe said.
useful (0)
These were fine, but nothing to write home about. I had trouble with the extra moisture from the pumpkin throwing the cook time off; my first batch was definitely underdone and even the more done ones were more moist than fluffy. I found them undersweetened, although maybe that's intentional because they were about right with syrup and candied pumpkin seeds.
The recipe also makes an enormous batch, so I'll be finding out how well they reheat.
useful (0)
Moosewood Cookbook
By Mollie Katzen
Ten Speed Press - 1992
Possibly the recipe which taught me that not all pasta is served in red sauce, and definitely the recipe which taught me that vegetarian entrees can make a whole meal. Spaghetti served with cauliflower, cheese, tomatoes, and spice - a delicious, hearty, satisfying dish.
useful (1)
I'm giving this a slightly higher rating than I think it deserves, because I suspect I made an important (and negative) change to the recipe by using ricotta cheese instead of cottage cheese. Truth is, I don't like stuffed squash very much, and this only seemed average to me. I am glad I used the optional handfuls of raisins and chopped pecans; they added good texture and flavor. (The recipe says walnuts, but as far as I'm concerned, every recipe which calls for walnuts is better with pecans.) All in all, not a bad way to make stuffed squash, just not exceptional.
useful (0)
It was only recently that I tasted borscht for the first time, and I knew I had to learn how to make it. It's fantastic comfort food; satisfying and rich, with balanced sweetness from the beets.
This recipe has the added benefit of being dead easy to make, especially if you let the food processor do the chopping like I did. (Like Queezle_Sister, I found some of the beet and carrot pieces too big at the end of cooking, so I hit it with the immersion blender to break them down a bit.)
I'll add a serving suggestion: horseradish. It adds a pleasant note of heat and a touch of acid to the soup. And don't forget a loaf of black bread.
useful (1)
I didn't care for this at all. The curry struck me as sandy, which I blame on the ground coconut. It was also somewhat bitter and unbalanced toward the pungent side of cloves, cumin, and cayenne. My wife thought it showed promise for further experiments (like substituting coconut milk for coconut flakes). I'd start with a new recipe... so we'll average those opinions and call it a 2.
I feel like this is a recipe which shows its age badly. One of the things that struck me is that, in 1977, you probably couldn't get decent curry paste or powder in most supermarkets. In 2011, I'm quite sure I could make curried cauliflower that's just as good or better with off-the-shelf ingredients, and I live in the sticks.
useful (1)
As a main course, this was disappointing. Hearty to be sure, but bland. It's certainly in the "comfort food" genre, but didn't quite make it for me... it got boring before it got homey. I might make it again as a side dish for a potluck, but not as an entree.
A warning - use your biggest pot. 2 pounds of raw spinach is a lot, as is 4 cups of cooked rice.
useful (3)
I'm a fan of potatoes and cabbage, so this dish caught my eye. With cider vinegar and 3 forms of tart dairy (cottage cheese, yogurt, and sour cream), it's a very rich dish but with a refreshing zing.
I certainly enjoyed it, but my family thought it was only OK. They prefer colcannon, which has the benefit of being a little less work. But I think I'll be tinkering with my colcannon recipe to see if I can get a little acidity into it, thanks to this recipe.
This is the second recipe in Moosewood which I think could be simplified by making it in a large (very large!) oven-safe skillet, or doing the sauteeing in a dutch oven. No sense dirtying 3 pots when 2 would do!
useful (3)
A recipe with good bones. I'm sure I'll be returning to it, with some tweaks perhaps to my ingredients and the recipe. Specifically, I cut the chili powder in half, to make sure my son would eat it. Not only will I use the whole amount next time, I might add something like a cubanelle pepper for a little more kick (and texture).
The mix of beans, cheese, tomato, and apple is like an interesting take on chili. Unfortunately, the Granny Smith apples I used were light on flavor. (Maybe that's what I get for buying apples in March in Ohio.) Next time, I might use a sweeter apple (although trying to keep the acidity and the way Granny Smith holds its shape).
Next time, I will also probably switch to a white bean, maybe Great Northern beans. This is not an appetizing recipe to look at. The red beans and light brown cooked apples just don't work for me.
This all sounds really critical, but it was hearty and rich, good for a main course (maybe served with rice) or a side dish (I enjoyed it with a pork loin roast). And it smells like a miracle coming out of the oven. I like it enough to make again, in fact, enough to put my own stamp on in future.
useful (2)
We made this without the mushrooms, which were missed, but it made a nice somewhat spicy soup. I tend to find butternut squash soup too sweet, but the heat and lack of dairy in this one seemed to help.
useful (0)
Website: The Minimalist (Mark Bittman)
topics.nytimes.com/top/features/diningandwine/columns/the_minimalist/index.html
"Loosely based on gumbo" is right - this stew cries out to be served over rice. It's hearty and succulent, although my first attempt was too salty. (Depending on how salty your bacon is, use a light touch in salting the cooking vegetables.) I also omitted the chiles when browning the meat, which was probably a mistake - a touch of hot sauce at the table woke it up a bit.
I do feel like there's an herbal note missing from this stew - perhaps because I'm mentally comparing it with gumbo. Thyme or a bay leaf, perhaps?
useful (0)
Mastering The Art of French Cooking, Volume One (1) (Vol 1)
By Julia Child, Louisette Bertholle, Simone Beck, Sidonie Coryn
Alfred A. Knopf - 2001
A dish which my wife and Nora Ephron both call "reason enough to own this cookbook." A delicious stew of lamb with spring vegetables like peas and green beans, and of course the usual cast of root vegetable characters.
useful (0)
I was familiar with the technique of browning pork chops and then reducing heat and braising. But I hadn't thought to use a low oven for that step, and it had never occurred to me to let the liquid be butter. A good, simple treatment, rich but not a lot of work.
I skipped the sauce, but it turns out cloves of garlic braised in butter are also a good thing...
useful (1)
This is one of those recipes that makes you yell "Eureka!" in the kitchen. Or possibly "Look what I have created!" like Tom Hanks in Castaway. Or "I read your book!" like George C. Scott in Patton. (OK, that one might just be me.)
It's easy, it's delicious, it sums up why we still revere Saint Julia. It's even funny - I won't spoil the joke, but don't miss the prologue to the recipe.
useful (1)
You know what's wrong with American hamburgers? Not enough butter. Well, Saint Julia knows the solution to that!
This opulent burger was a big hit in our house. I think of thyme as more of a friend to beans and pork than beef, but it lends these burgers an interesting depth of flavor. And oh, the butter... onions sauteed in butter, butter added to the meat, fry the burgers in butter. (In retrospect, I wish I'd read Julia's notes closer and gotten 90% lean ground beef instead of 80%.) The wine reduction (finished with butter, natch) made an interesting condiment - not exactly like steak sauce, but more like that than anything else I can think of.
Serve on a hearty bun with a lettuce leaf and pickles.
useful (2)
It's just a baked custard with fruit on the bottom. Except for the fact that the flan is as silky as love, and the sweet egg and vanilla are the home of a childhood memory. It takes time, but so little effort, that I have to wonder why I haven't been making at least one a week.
I used the Lee Brothers brandied plums, instead of Julia's recipe, which worked just fine (and brought a bit of cinnamon to the mix). I forgot to swap in some of the plummed brandy for milk, which would have increased the fruit flavor.
An hour would have been a little too long in my oven; don't be afraid to start checking at 50 minutes or so.
useful (3)
A lovely easy technique for turnips. "Braised in butter" isn't actually as over-the-top as I thought - most of the braising liquid is stock or water. (And I probably used too much of it - I suspect "barely covered" actually means "not quite covered".) Definitely an improvement over just boiling them.
useful (1)
With cream, Marsala, tarragon, and Swiss cheese, these are much sweeter than the "mushrooms stuffed with herb cream cheese" that I remember from family holidays. They are refined and delicious, if a tad oily, and play well with other foods. That said, they are more effort than the old family "open a container" recipe; it'll be a matter of personal preferences whether that effort pays off.
useful (0)
Good spongecake recipe, lightly flavored with orange. The outer edge of our cake came out just a hair tough, which might be related to the fact that we used a 10-inch pan instead of the 9-inch called for. A big hit with some whipped cream and vanilla ice cream.
useful (0)
Fun treatment for chicken. We didn't serve it with the brown butter sauce, but instead heated up a little tomato sauce and made an ersatz chicken parmigiana.
useful (0)
Very successful in my house. A lighter treatment than a cheesy "au gratin" but the butter and tomatoes add some richness. It would be good with a piece of fish.
useful (1)
Yup, it's blanched cauliflower. Though I must admit salting the water is a good step.
useful (0)
It is a delicious baked custard, but I found my cherries lacking in flavor. I wish I'd taken the step to soak them in a liqueur (like the next recipe in the book states). Or maybe just a little cinnamon or nutmeg over the top.
Would definitely make again, but I'll check the intensity of the cherries' flavor and make adjustments next time.
useful (0)
Mary Gwynn's 30-Minute Vegetarian Recipes
By Mary Gwynn
Meredith Corporation - 1996
A terrific, simple breakfast course. Kind of an upscale egg mcmuffin, with goat cheese standing in for the saltiness of bacon. My wife hates olives, so we omit the olive paste and frequently use anchovy paste instead.
useful (0)
A pleasant approach to tomato-cream sauce. It comes together easily and retains just enough texture to be interesting. I find it missing a little brightness, but as creamed tomato sauces go, it's a great payoff for the light effort.
useful (0)
Website: Martha Stewart
The garlic puree/marinade has some good flavors; we actually let it sit overnight and that seems like a good choice. I was pleasantly surprised that the temperature and cook time did not dry out the pork or burn the greens. Unfortunately, the water that's keeping things moist also seemed to keep them from browning.
Overall, I felt like this whole recipe needed a little more oomph. There's not nearly enough heat or acidity to the greens. The garlicky pork is nice, but I felt it wanted some brown sugar and maybe some cayenne. (Or maybe just a whole mess more garlic and oregano and a little more orange juice.)
I'd tinker with it some more; the pork did come out nicely. But it was underwhelming.
useful (0)
Website: Manger a Trois
This is a terrific glaze for roast pork. I also hadn't considered the step of coating the meat with corn starch before searing; it didn't form much of a crust for me but did make the presentation very nice (and probably held the glaze better).
I made this with a boneless pork loin, not tenderloin, but I think it worked fine.
useful (0)
Website: Lidia's Italy
A fantastic dish for spring or early summer, this is a dish that's hearty without being heavy. It's a dish of little bites... a bit of salt from the pancetta, cubes of sweet potato which retain their shape, and a hit of freshness from the vinegary capers.
useful (0)
Website: Lemon Blossoms
This was only OK. I felt like something was missing from the sauce - like the pungency of lime and garlic cooked down too much in the slow cooker. Still, it's low effort and worth more experiments.
useful (0)
The Lee Bros. Simple Fresh Southern: Knockout Dishes with Down-Home Flavor
By Matt Lee, Ted Lee
Clarkson Potter - 2009
Seems like a promising recipe, even if I had something of a cooking fail. (I forgot to mix the brown sugar and spices with the lemon juice before pouring the whole mess over the sweet potatoes - so mine were kind of sweeter on one side and lemony on the other. Weird, but good enough.)
Sweet potatoes in my world are usually either baked in their jackets, or mashed, so this recipe of baked slices minimally spiced was a revelation. They maintain some structure and texture, and a good amount of clear sweet potato flavor.
They did hold pretty well overnight - I made these the night before Thanksgiving and served them on the day.
useful (0)
I had no idea that soft cheese was either so easy to make or so delicious. This recipe takes you from having cold milk to a delectable, rich, salty-tangy ricotta-like cheese in under half an hour. I'm just stunned, and looking for opportunities to show this off. (And no one will judge you if you scrape the cheesecloth clean as a cook's treat...)
I tried the lemon zest variant, which smelled outstanding, and married well with the pecan-crusted treatment. A drizzle of honey really brought out the zing of the lemon; it was a hit on a dessert buffet.
A few notes - the Lee brothers think this recipe takes 8 minutes of cooking; I think either their definition of "medium" heat is higher than mine, or my fridge is colder than theirs, because it definitely took longer than that for curds to develop for me. That said, I also feel sure I cooked it longer than necessary, hoping to see cottage-cheese size curds which never developed. The curds will be fine, but the cheesecloth will catch them.
I also have to admit that I didn't have whole milk on hand as called for, but I did have whipping cream. I don't know if 1 cup cream + 3 cups of 1% milk = 1 quart of whole milk or not - but it works fine for this recipe.
useful (1)
I only made the mushroom chutney; the chops look like a pretty basic preparation so there seems like no reason to doubt it. I really enjoyed the chutney, although I find the prunes are really the dominant flavor, with the earthiness of the mushrooms a distant second. It would be an excellent compliment for pork or chicken (or maybe even fish) - unfortunately, I served it with beef, and the flavors seemed to fight. I'm wondering if cutting the prunes way, way back would let the mushrooms and beef pairing work better.
One warning - the recipe says to use a 12" skillet, and I tried this in my 10", and just barely did everything fit. I also needed to cook it a lot longer than the recipe says to get the sauce to reduce. Seriously, use a 12" or bigger pan.
useful (1)
A light and spongy cake, still very moist, and packed with vanilla flavor. A phenomenal base for almost any kind of dessert sauce you could imagine putting on it. The only problem is that a dessert this small and light is either for the end of a big meal... or you want to eat all 8 of them yourself.
(Also, the Lee Brothers' nonstick pans must work better than mine - I didn't grease the pan and they stuck monstrously.)
useful (0)
I don't think my attempt went quite right, but I'm giving this a good rating for promise. I initially thought the sauce was a little too minty - 8 springs of mint, at least from my garden, is powerful. But it's a pleasantly delicate sauce, not heavy like it looks.
I've found that steelhead trout can almost always stand in for salmon, so that's what I used for this recipe. It didn't quite work, and I don't know if that's because of the fish itself, or because I didn't char the skin hard enough, or what. It was good - what's wrong with a recipe that boils down to "salt, pepper, broil" - but not great. But I'm going to cheat my rating up because maybe that's cook's error.
useful (0)
It's not really fair to make a dish like this right after 4 inches of snow falls. Satisfying but light, we had fun imagining what cook-out food it might go with. (We're thinking grilled chicken or shrimp.) It's light and cool, but with pleasant acidity and a hit of herbs. It worked just fine as a way to use up some leftover rice and an open can of chopped tomatoes. I'm looking forward to making it with fresh ingredients this summer.
Now all I have to do is get to the thaw.
useful (1)
As a rule, I trust people when they name a dish after a family member. They way I see it, any honorable person will bring their A game when they play under Gran's flag... and for that matter, I want to know if you're not honorable.
I'm here to report that the Lee Brothers are proper Southern boys who wouldn't let you think bad of dear old Gran. This is a fabulous marinade which I see becoming part of my regular rotation. The bourbon-soy combination makes for a smoky taste which you'd swear came from a barbecue, and then it reduces to a delicious pan sauce. It's clearly superior to any London broil I've had.
About halfway through dinner, I realized I was hungry for a crusty sandwich roll. I'm thinking this would be a fantastic sandwich au jus (perhaps with lettuce, caramelized onions, and maybe a bit of brie or mayo).
useful (1)
A very pleasant fry-up of eggs, onions, and tortilla chips. The technique of adding the eggs to the hot onions (and then topping with cheese) makes this a very forgiving recipe.
A few notes - I like the serving suggestion that migas could be served with a bowl of greens, but "atop a bed of greens" didn't work for me. (The greens overwhelm the eggs.) A cup of chili would also be very nice, as they serve it at the Texas Chili Parlor in Austin. Actually, I bet there's a lot of leftovers which would pair up well with migas for breakfast the next day.
Think of the balance of onions, eggs, and tortillas as a guideline, not a rule. We found 6 medium eggs to 3 tortillas to be about right, but the "medium" onion was too much (for me, by a little, for my wife, by a lot). The recipe calls for 8 large eggs, so that's no surprise.
Making your own tortilla chips is cheaper than buying them, and what's more, now I have tortillas to cook with, not a pound bag of chips to snack on without thinking. That said, using store-bought chips won't hurt anything and will save time.
useful (0)
Light and refreshing, and easy to boot. The milk and mint flavor suggests a faint drizzle of chocolate sauce. Ours were silky almost to the point of lacking structural integrity, and took more than the stated 1.5 hours to set up; I suspect the answer in both cases is that our ramekins are deeper than they are wide. A different shape might set up firmer (or I might use the whole packet of gelatin powder next time).
useful (0)
Imagine the end of a summer meal in the south. You want just a little something for dessert, something comforting, reminding you of home, but nothing too heavy. Something you could savor slowly on the porch swing, maybe with a beer or cocktail.
That's what the Lee brothers have cooked up with this frozen rice pudding pop. It's a novelty act, with a texture that's not quite popsicle, not quite ice cream, and certainly no longer pudding. Eventually you realize how the cold is muting the flavors... on the 2nd or 3rd pop. But what the heck - it's hot out, and you have a treat simultaneously refreshing and satisfying.
One tip - this recipe claims to make six 4-ounce pops. I made twelve 2-ounce pops, and easily had enough for another 6. If you don't tell anyone about this and stash the leftovers in the fridge, you can have sweet cool rice porridge for breakfast.
useful (0)
I enjoyed the flavor of these fritters. The sweet potato base works nicely with the vegetal okra and pungent onion. The technique was a trick though... the process was easy enough but I'm still not sure if I was trying to get more of a potato pancake thickness or a hush puppy. (Presumably the answer is "in between.") Obviously, this affects the texture and cooking time. I probably will try again to see if I can get a more consistent product.
The dipping sauce is just a mix of buttermilk, sour cream, and a microplaned clove of garlic. I don't know why this isn't on the table every night.
One kitchen note - you're going to purge liquid out of the sweet potato and chop okra. You will get wet on this ride.
useful (1)
After 24 hours in the fridge, we broke these out, and my wife said "it tastes like Christmas." The mix of brandy and cinnamon and plum does taste like something you'd expect to find on a holiday table. I wonder how it would hold up as a fruitcake ingredient. (In fact, I imagined it as a special Christmas-stocking candy.)
Of course, all the talk of Christmas makes me wonder if the recipe would have to change to make them store well. We'll pay attention as we nibble the jar down over the next few weeks... for science.
In the meantime, I'm wondering how to pair them. Vanilla ice cream or whipped cream seems obvious, as would a shortcake. I'm tempted by the idea that these might work in something like a clafouti or even an upside-down cake.
I made a half-batch, and frankly, it doesn't save enough work to be worth it. The Lees are right; make two jars and, if you won't use them, give them away.
useful (0)
Take a dry sparkling wine (like a cava or a prosecco), and add a plum-infused brandy syrup. Crisp and refreshing, this is a drink which could play many parts - a summer cocktail, an aperitif or a dessert drink. The brandy, plum, and cinnamon, though, evoke Christmas. This is a drink that whispers "God bless us, every one." And it certainly helps the brandied plum recipe from the dessert section pay off.
useful (0)
I made this with ham hock meat instead of chorizo, which I suspect was a mistake. The combination of sauteed greens and poblanos is pretty nice, but this recipe seems to be counting on the spice and fat from sausage, and the ham hocks' salt and smoke just isn't cutting it. I also prefer my greens very vinegary, and the 2 tablespoons called for in this recipe don't lend enough brightness for my taste.
useful (0)
I slapped a partial recipe together in a little bit of time before dinner, and it was pretty pleasant. Once the red wine actually penetrates the carrots and turnips, the sweet notes of all three become very interesting and complex. I'll definitely return to this following the recipe more closely (and allowing a more proper amount of time to marinade).
useful (0)
Website: The Kitchn
Worked pretty well, and made me less afraid of the time and effort needed for paella. Mine needed salt, and benefited from a drizzle of olive oil at the end. I also messed up by adding too many frozen peas, which sucked up a lot of the heat which was supposed to be cooking the shrimp, which led my "crunchy rice" into just burned territory. I might go ahead and pan-sear the shrimp next time, for more control over flavor and texture.
useful (0)
Website: Kevin Dundon
Exceptionally good technique for trout - perfectly done, wrapped in crispy bacon, and not a hint of sticking to the pan. I'll be returning to this many times. It also has a lovely mix of textures, with firm fish, crispy-chewy bacon, and shattering slivers of almonds.
The sauce didn't work perfectly for me. I think I misunderstood an instruction that the oil in the pan needed to be dumped and replaced with just butter, because mine came out very oily and perhaps not lemony enough. The flavors are there, but I didn't get them in the right balance.
useful (0)
Website: Kevin Dundon
I'm not quite getting the point of this dish. It's leeks in a cheese sauce - a fair side dish, but not terribly interesting.
useful (0)
Website: Just a Pinch Recipes
My family and I love fried beet chips, but there's a tiny window of opportunity between soggy, not quite done chips and burned ones. (Frying red chips in a black cast iron pan doesn't help know where that window is.)
So we greeted this recipe with a little excitement. Unfortunately, I cut the beets on my mandolin at 3 mm, which turned out to be too wide. They were still tasty, but they were frankly chewy. Next time I'll go down to 1.5 mm (or maybe even to .75, which is way too thin for the deep fryer).
Use a liberal hand when brushing on the olive oil.
(Edit: Yup, 1.5 mm was better, and it's what most recipes call for, but it needs a little more time to get crispy. I'll do .75 mm next time.)
(Edit to the edit: .75 works really well, but they're done in under 15 minutes.)
useful (0)